🎸 The Power of the Pick: Materials, Thickness, and Tone
Published: November 18, 2025
Whether you're strumming an acoustic ballad or shredding through a solo, the humble guitar pick plays a surprisingly powerful role in shaping your sound. At Gannon Luthier, we believe every detail matters — and that includes the tool between your fingers.
🧵 Materials Matter: What Picks Are Made Of
Guitar picks (or plectrums) are produced in a wide variety of materials, with each type offering a different feel, durability, and most importantly, a distinct impact on your tone.
The materials can generally be grouped into a few categories:
1. Plastics (Most Common)
The vast majority of modern guitar picks are made from various plastics, often with specific brand names.
Celluloid: Historically the first plastic used. It offers a warm, vintage, and balanced tone and is often flexible. It was created to mimic the look and feel of tortoiseshell.
Nylon: A very popular material, known for being flexible (especially in thinner gauges) and producing a softer, warmer, or mellower tone. Many are textured for better grip.
Acetal (Delrin/Tortex/Delrex): These are different trade names for a durable plastic known for its good grip and producing a balanced to bright and crisp sound. Tortex (a Dunlop brand) is particularly famous.
Polyetherimide (Ultem/Ultex): An extremely durable, rigid, and heat-resistant plastic that offers a bright, clear, and defined tone with excellent articulation, often favored for fast playing.
Acrylic: Tough and clear, acrylic picks can have a unique "tacky" feel when warmed by the fingers, offering great grip. They often produce a bright sound.
Carbon Fiber: Extremely durable and stiff, providing a bright, clear tone with a strong attack.
2. Natural Materials & Derivatives
These materials often offer unique tonal characteristics and feel, and some are now synthetic or banned due to conservation efforts.
Tortoiseshell (Banned): Once considered the "holy grail" of pick materials for its rich tone and low friction, it is now illegal to buy or sell due to the endangered status of the hawksbill sea turtle. Modern picks like celluloid and Tortex seek to replicate its properties.
Wood: Different hardwoods (like African Blackwood, Cocobolo, or Rosewood) are used to create picks that typically offer a unique, organic, and warm tone compared to plastic.
Bone / Horn: Hard and dense natural materials that are durable and produce a round sound with good low and midrange frequencies.
3. Hard Materials
These are less common for general playing but are chosen for their specific tonal qualities, durability, and rigidity.
Metal (e.g., Stainless Steel, Brass, Copper): Extremely durable and rigid. They produce a very bright, articulate, and metallic tone with high sustain, but can be harder on your strings.
Stone (e.g., Jade, Agate): Very rigid picks that command a thumping or clear, bright tone and are primarily used for single-note lines rather than strumming.
Glass / Ceramic: Also very hard, offering a different feel and bright tonal qualities.
The best pick material is highly subjective and depends on the genre, instrument (acoustic vs. electric), and the player's desired tone and feel.
Each material affects not just tone, but how the pick glides across strings, how it grips in your hand, and how it wears over time.
📏 Thickness: Feel vs. Flex
Guitar pick thickness, or gauge, is measured in millimeters (mm) and has a significant impact on how you play and the tone you get. Thicknesses generally range from about 0.38 mm up to 3.0 mm or more and are often grouped into four main categories.
Extra Light / Light
Gauge: 0.38−0.60 mm
Tone & Feel: Bright, chimey, and loud. Very flexible, providing an easy, natural compression to control volume and prevent string breakage.
Best For: Acoustic strumming, beginner players.
Medium
Gauge: 0.60−0.80 mm
Tone & Feel: Balanced. Warm, loud, and full. Offers better control, precision, and a thicker, fuller tone with more attack and volume.
Best For: General use, light electric strumming, and rhythm playing.
Heavy
Gauge: 0.80−1.20 mm
Tone & Feel: Warm, loud, and full. Offers better control, precision, and a thicker, fuller tone with more attack and volume.
Best For: Electric rhythm, hard strumming, and lead guitar playing.
Extra Heavy
Gauge: 1.20 mm an up
Tone & Feel: Darker, highly articulate, and powerful. Maximum control and precision for fast picking, with little to no flex.
Best For: Solo/lead guitar, jazz, metal, and bass guitar.
Thinner picks bend easily and produce a lighter sound, while thicker picks offer control and depth — especially useful for solos and technical passages.
🎸 How Thickness Affects Play
Strumming: Thinner picks are generally better for strumming on acoustic guitars because their flexibility allows them to glide over the strings, creating a smooth, even, and chimey sound.
Lead Playing: Thicker picks are preferred for lead guitar and single-note playing, as the lack of flex provides better control, speed, and precision for alternate picking, yielding a louder, warmer, and more articulate tone.
Tone: Thinner picks produce a brighter tone due to the subtle "click" or "slap" sound as the pick flexes against the string. Thicker picks produce a fuller, darker tone, emphasizing the natural sound of the string and guitar.
🎸 The Shape of the Pick Matters
The shape of a guitar pick is the third major variable (after material and thickness) that dramatically affects your grip, control, and tone.
Here are the main pick shapes and their typical uses:
🌟 The Standard Shape (Fender 351 Style):
This is the most common and recognizable shape, the classic "teardrop" with a slightly pointed tip and a wide, rounded base.
Description: A large, familiar pick with one rounded corner for grip and one relatively sharp corner for picking.
Best Suited For: All-around p laying; excellent for rhythm guitar and general strumming across all genres (rock, pop, folk). It is the most versatile shape.
Impact on Tone/Play: The generous size is easy to hold for beginners, and the moderately sharp tip provides a good balance between the smooth feel of a rounded pick and the precision of a sharp pick.
📐 The Triangle/Large Triangle Shape (Fender 346/355 Style):
This is a much larger pick that is nearly an equilateral triangle.
Description: Features three identical rounded or slightly pointed tips. Much larger body than the Standard pick.
Best Suited For: Rhythm guitar, bass guitar, and players with large hands: Ideal for heavy strumming or flatpicking where grip and stability are paramount.
Impact on Tone/Play: The size makes it harder to drop and offers a wide surface for a secure grip. Since all three corners are usually the same, you have three usable playing tips, which means the pick lasts three times longer.
🚀 The Jazz/Teardrop Shape (Dunlop Jazz III Style):
The Jazz pick is a variation of the standard shape that is significantly smaller and often thicker. Description: Smaller body and a much sharper, more pointed tip than the standard pick.
Best Suited For: Lead guitar, fast solos, jazz, and metal/shredding. Any style requiring extreme precision and speed.
Impact on Tone/Play: The small size and sharp point offer maximum control and accuracy. The sharp tip provides a strong, bright, and articulate attack that is crucial for high-speed alternate picking and clear single-note lines.
🦈 Specialty and Niche Shapes:
Beyond the main three, there are unique shapes designed for specific techniques:
Thumb Pick: A plastic or metal band worn over the thumb, often with a large, rigid tip.
Best Suited For: Maximum attack and volume (especially country, bluegrass) to give the thumb a powerful, consistent attack while the fingers pluck.
Sharp / Pointy: A standard or teardrop shape, but with the tip filed down to an extreme, needle-like point.
Best Suited For: Fingerstyle guitar for technical/fast lead playing. Can generate a brighter, more aggressive tone.
Rounded: A pick with a serrated/jagged edge on one side and a rounded edge on the other, offering multiple playing surfaces.
Best Suited For: Mellow tone for strumming; reduces pick noise and string wear, often preferred by some acoustic and jazz players for a soft attack.
Shark Fin: A standard or teardrop shape, but with the tip filed down to an extreme, needle-like point.
Best Suited For: Allows a player to quickly switch between a sharp attack (using the point) and a raspy, raking sound (using the jagged side).
Ultimately, the best pick for any player is the one that combines the ideal material, thickness, and shape to produce the desired tone and feel comfortable in their hand.
← Back to All Blogs
